Log in

View Full Version : Valentine's Day Show Review


Vash2003skate
02-09-2003, 09:38 PM
Hallmark Valentine’s Day showcase of figure skating in Tucson,Arizona on Jan. 14th, 2003

The show was FABULOUS. It was a night of PURE skating, without the silliness you see in SOI or the ‘cheap entertainment’ of COI. This event was not well attended- lack of advertisting may be? Even the small arena was less than one third filled. The crowd was very enthusiastic, however, so you could not tell from the noise that it was such a small group. Since this is going to be televised (CBS, Feb. 9th), digital cameras, flash photos were not allowed. The ice was flooded with purple light. Verne Lundquist did the intro.

There were 5 pairs (Berezhnaya-Sikharulidze, Sale-Pelletier, Ina-Zimmerman, Meno-Sand, Langlois-Archetto), 2 ice dance couples (Roca-Sur, and Krylova-Ovssianikov), and 1 soloist (Katia Gordeeva). Each performed two numbers- one before and one after the intermission. Even Langlois-Archetto- the Canadian amateur (eligible) pair did two numbers. Most of the cast was from Stars on Ice, so the numbers were from the show.

During the first number, which was a group number with all the skaters, a few took the ice at a time. First the dance couples. Next the pairs. First S&P and Meno-Sand. Elena and Anton waited for their turn on the ice, in a corner that was just 10-15 feet from where I sat. They and I&Z took the ice together and did star lifts, but Elena came down immediately because her dress came undone and she and Anton had to get off the ice to fix it. They redid it at the end so that it could be patched in for the telecast. Next, Katia came on the ice and did a pair element with each of the 4 SOI men. She did a pairs spin with John, a death spiral with Todd (I think), and a lift with Anton. She did a sbs spin with David, but they were far apart (not surprising for a 'pair' that does not train together).

What I liked about this show was that there was a nice mixture of serious and funny numbers but there was nothing cheap about the fun numbers. They were cute and required skill. Jenny & Todd’s “I am your man” was a lot of fun. I have always found Jenny & Todd boring on TV but quite good in live performances. They performed very well in this show.

Jamie and David’s first number ‘Come fly with me’ was fun. It was choreographed by Seibert and Dean. The second number was just OK, though the crowd seemed to like it a lot (not as much as the first one though). I discovered later that it was choreo’ed by Sandra Bezic. That just confirmed my belief that Sandra is a good choreographer for singles but not for pairs. J&D’s BODS was on a Huge curve and was very well done. Jamie landed both throws, but as always she just landed it and moved on to something else without holding the edge. Her dress in the first number was lovely- yellow and white. David seemed to be really enjoying himself, particularly the first number was very well skated.

Elena and Anton performed Meditation in the first half. They were really on. This was the last number of the half. They stood there for a long time, taking the bows. I think it was their way of thanking the audience. Meditation was one of the highlights of the show.

In the second half they performed ‘Mme T. after Dark. They stood on the ice as two covered statues in Madame Tussod’s wax museum. Gorsha Sur stood next to Elena who was covered with a sheet, then he stepped off the ice. Anton threw off his sheet first and skated toward Elena. Gorsha went to the ice and picked up the sheet. Elena’s sheet was pulled off from the top by equipment. The crowd absolutely loved Anton’s Elvis impersonation. They loved it when Elena started performing as Marilyn. She has rearranged her hair for this number (loose, short) to appear more like Marilyn Monroe and it worked much better than what I had seen on TV (earlier SOI, and Hallmark Salute to gold). When the music slowed down, the crowd became a bit quiet, but again when the music picked up (Hound dog), the crowd cheered louder. I was surprised that the upside down split did not receive much attention. From where I was, I could only see Anton’s back during this move. I will get to see it during SOI on Jan. 16th. This number is definitely meant to be a crowd pleaser. It is still evolving. They are now doing spiral into throw triple loop. I have to admit that I enjoyed watching this number, though it is not classic B&S. Meditation from Thais is the perfect piece of music and the perfect number for them. Everytime they perform it, they receive a HUGE response. Elvis & Marilyn also received a BIG response from the audience. BTW this number has been choreo’ed by Bobrin and Moskvina.

Another highlight was Krylova-Ovssianikov’s Ave Maria, which was simply exquisite. They performed it in the second half. In the first half they skated to Last of the Mohicans. I liked Anjelika’s new outfit much better than her last year’s bare back outfit. The crowd loved them and they got HUGE ovations. Anjelika is so tall ( 5ft 8 in.) and Oleg is so big and passionate- they both are- they fill the ice with their presence. Their speed and passion is amazing.

Roca-Sur skated the Prayer and the other number extraordinarily well. Rene has gotten rid of her stiff arms which used to bother me a lot. They have evolved into beautiful ice dancers. BTW The Prayer was choreo’ed by Dean. No wonder I like it. Is it my imagination that Rene resembles Sarah Hughes? They could be sisters!

At the start of the second half, Jenny-Todd, Rene-Gorsha and Kyoko-John skated a group routine to ‘Something stupid’. It was very cute. It must be a part of the SOI tour.

Kyoko & John did sbs single axels in both their programs. I liked Glory Halelujah (sung by Elvis) a lot. This number was one of the highlights of the show. They did not do the last lift where Kyoko stands on his legs while he is in spread eagles. It was one of my less liked moves. You really see Tamara’s influence not only in their choreography but in the way Kyoko stretches her arms (John was always elegant). She used to be a jumper who never paid attention to lines.

Langlois-Archetto seemed a bit out of place in a group of mature skaters. They are not that developed and I wondered why they were there. May be another pair had canceled out at the last minute, or CBS just wanted to make the show longer, and no one else was available..? Woetzel-Stoyer or Sato Dungjen or Kazakova-Dmitriev or Brasseur-Eisler would have been more appropriate. Langois-Archetto skated well, however. I winced when they did the head banger in their second program. It is my most hated move in skating. They did the leap of faith and it was done well.

The show was well designed. Not only did it have dignity, but the order of skates was well thought out. In the first half Elena & Anton skated the last number. Just before that, Katia skated a Russian folk music number. Before her, Rene-Gorsha and Jamie and David skated their first number. In the second half, Jamie and David skated last. Katia skated before them, and Elena-Anton skated before Katia.

I had wondered before the show why Katia was there- in a couples’ show. After the show the reasons were clear to me…1)she is a big draw, 2)her presence diffused the attention from the two most talked about pairs, because her numbers separated their numbers. She was the darling of the crowd. Her edging is so soft and beautiful, her lines are so elegant and well developed. She was having trouble with the jumps because her body has changed so much. She had to redo 4 jumps at the end, and she needed at least 2 attempts for each (except for the double axel). That must have been exhausting.

At the end, each pair was reintroduced. The man from the new pair would give flowers to the lady from the first pair. J&D were already on the ice, since they skated last. So E&A were the last couple to step on the ice. David gave flowers to Elena. Next, Katia stepped on the ice and Anton gave her flowers.

They did not go around the ice like I have seen in all the other shows I have been to. I took a group photo when they all stood together on the ice at the end.

After a short break those who faltered during the performance had to redo it. From jenny & Todd we will see ‘First time ever I saw your face’. Jenny fell on the throw double axel during the performance and had to do it 3 times before getting it right. She looked tired and a bit frustrated at the end.

Of course Elena & Anton, and Kyoko& John had to redo their starting group number, after Elena got her dress fixed. It went beyond it, and Katia did pairs elements with John and Todd. Next, she and Anton started moving across the ice to do the lift but the people in charge asked them to stop because it was not needed. They looked disappointed and the crowd did too.

Verne Lundquist did an excellent job as the announcer. I really enjoyed the show. It was money well spent.

Vash

bleu
02-09-2003, 10:20 PM
As a pair fan, I enjoyed the program very well. I am going to comment on all of them.

1.) Meno and Sand - I like this number over their current SOI number. They skate as though it is only them in the arena. Another treat was hearing Todd say that he enjoys skating romantic numbers with his wife.
Pairwise - they did alot of carrying lifts! I would like to see them doing more SBS spins or even sit spins just so people see the variety in their skating.

2.) Zimmerman & Ina - I am really impressed with their transformation from amateurs to pro. I never really paid attention to them but I am begining to like what I see. Ahem...nothing to do with the leather ;). Noticed how they did SBS spins and jumps. I hope they don't ever forego the technical difficulty. Bravo to them. Hopefully they will develop their skating further.

3.) Roca & Sur - I can't remember much because I was too distracted with that bare minimum costume of hers. I will go with their SOI number instead. Tell me something, I have seen their SOI number and this one but where are the twizzles of ice dancing? I keep wondering if they are dancers. Or am I imagining them as dancers when they are pairs skaters.

4.) They chacked K&O - :evil: I was so looking forward to see this pair since eons ago. :x

5.) Elena & Anton - they skated well to this music. He is so expressive!!!. It is nice to see a pair where the man shines more than the woman. Notice how at the end of the program, Anton opened his mouth wide and looked like he was going to eat her meanwhile Elena looked just too happy. :lol: :lol:

6.) Jamie & David - Come Fly with Me - polished, pure joy and vintage S&P. Only they can project "happiness" on ice. Seeing it live is a very special treat. I am so glad that this number was shown. Lovin' Touchin' and Squeezin' - very sensual and a primo example of chemistry a la post graduate studies. LOL.

All in all great show.

Vash2003skate
02-09-2003, 10:48 PM
I don't believe that Anton shines more than Elena. They are equal. We are used to seeing a man just presenting his partner, except when Artur Dmitriev skated. Anton has Artur's passion as well as technical skills comparable with Sergei's, which makes it very enjoyable to watch him. He is one of the few male partners that can present the lady without losing his own identity.

Vash

Vash2003skate
02-09-2003, 11:06 PM
I found CBS's 1 hour coverage of this event to be less than satisfactory. The live show gave equal importance to all skaters- two performances each (plus a group number for 3 couples). CBS showed two performances of S&P but none of Krylova-Ovssianikov's. Both K&O performances were received extremely well by the crowd. I have never seen their Ave Maria televised, so my only memory is from the live performance. K&O are two-time world champions and 1998 Olympic silver medallists. They deserve better treatment.

Langlois & Archetto skated two performances, but they were not even introduced in CBS's telecast. Why invite skaters to perform in a show and then act like they were not there?

IMO CBS should have dropped the group number 'Something Stupid' and one of S&P numbers to make room for one each of K&O and L&A, or they should have made this a 90 minute show instead of 60 minutes.

Vash

dmr65
02-10-2003, 06:07 AM
5.) Elena & Anton - they skated well to this music. He is so expressive!!!. It is nice to see a pair where the man shines more than the woman. Notice how at the end of the program, Anton opened his mouth wide and looked like he was going to eat her meanwhile Elena looked just too happy.

I recall in the past fans criticizing Anton for being the more expressive one. It's interesting to hear someone say they don't mind it. I agree, he is more expressive. No offense to Elena. They compliment each other well, though.

My opinions

Even though I am a huge fan of Artur, I think Anton is a more gentle, artistic, passionate, classical and energetic skater, where Artur is passionate, powerful and artistic. Artur puts a bit more imagination into his skating, that is what makes him exciting to me.

I don't know if it's a Moskvina thing, but I notice her two male pairs seem to be more expressive and dominating than their partners. But Oksana came into her own very well, and Elena is a Rose in bloom.

bleu
02-10-2003, 08:31 AM
Thanks Denise,

Vash - I see this once in a while in the junior pairs and some senior pairs in Canada. Even certain popular skaters today once had partners who didn't stand out much as they are. Example, David Pelletier. I had the privilege of seeing him with another partner beside Jamie. He stood out. You can't always have pairs that are equally charismatic. Personally, it is fine with me. Another thing is that what I am talking about has nothing to do with presenting the woman. That is a style that Moskvina likes but I doubt it has anything to do with which partner is more out than the other.

Messalina
02-10-2003, 04:42 PM
It was a huge disappointment to me that they chacked O&K - the only reason I actually watched this show. (The schmaltz factor bothers me so much that I had to fast-forward through numbers like, for instance, "Something Stupid.") Loved S&P's "Come Fly with Me," however. Perfect for them and their incredible, happy-go-lucky esprit.

They did not do the last lift where Kyoko stands on his legs while he is in spread eagles.

And yet I swear I saw that in there! Did my eyes deceive me?

Meredith
02-10-2003, 05:05 PM
No, your eyes did not deceive you. The spiral was in the middle of the program, not the end.

Artemis
02-11-2003, 12:06 PM
Originally posted by Vash2003skate
I found CBS's 1 hour coverage of this event to be less than satisfactory. ...

Hey, at least you got to see something. The Seattle CBS affliliate decided not to show it at all ... and instead we got a 1-hour infomercial. :evil:

Vash2003skate
02-11-2003, 09:30 PM
That sounds terrible, Artemis. I just heard CBS is going to show it again on Feb.22nd- a 2 hour program. I hope this is not just a rumor.

Vash