Log in

View Full Version : COI Review - D.C.


Debbie S
04-15-2007, 02:30 PM
I posted this on another forum and didn't see any tour reviews here so I thought I'd post it here as well. I saw the Wash, D.C. show yesterday with my mom. Overall, we enjoyed it (although it started off on a sour note when the usher at the door made me throw away my bottled water, which hadn't even been opened yet :twisted: ). At Worlds in '03, we were allowed in with bottled water all week, just like in St. Louis last year at Nats. WTF? And then the guy demanded that I come back after throwing the bottle away (in a trash can about 8 feet from the checkpoint) so that he could check me again. For crying out loud, aren't there more important things to worry about than bottled water? :roll:

It was strange and a bit sad not to see Michelle Kwan. And the arena was barely half full. The lower bowl sections along the long axis of the arena were pretty full, but the area around the corners was pretty empty, except for the lower rows. The second tier was pretty sparse. Audience reaction seemed muted for most numbers - Kimmie, Sasha, and Evan got the most applause, I think.

Warning: Irina Grigorian appears not once (which is too much for me, sorry) but twice! Once near the end of the first act, where she twirls a cube (no hoops) and then takes off her skates and rolls around in a human-sized version of an exercise wheel that you'd put in the cage of your pet hamster. Did I mention that she was dressed as Cat Woman? :roll: She then leads off the second act (maybe this was to have filler so those stuck in ladies' room lines wouldn't miss anything interesting?) and does her usual hoop-twirling thing. Sheesh! Wasn't anyone else available to take the extra spot vacated by Irina Slutskaya? Emily Hughes? Greg/Pet? Davis/White? Castile/Okolski? Somebody? Anybody?!!!:twisted:

Anyway, the show started off with Ryan Bradley doing a modified version of his "Saturday Night Fever" LP from last year. Lots of flips and arabian-type gymnastic moves. A few jumps and spins. Alissa Czisny was next skating to Sarah Brightman's "Anytime, Anywhere". Beautiful skating, even if she did underrotate and 2-foot a 3 lutz and 3 flip. Nice 2 axel, though. At the beginning, when the music was very light, she started off with a couple of back cross strokes and I could hear the edge rips from the 14th row. I'm really struggling with those on the (Adult) Silver MIF test and I was in awe of how neat and easy she made it look.

The order of the rest of the first act is a bit fuzzy, but it included Dan Hollander (new number, with costume changes between Batman, Wonder Woman, and Superman) - typical, silly stuff - I know he's on the tour for the comic relief, but I wish he'd get to do a semi-serious skating number once in a while; Rudy Galindo in a typical Rudy performance - does a costume change in the middle, in an ad hoc change room on the ice that consisted of a curtain strung around a circular rod that Shae-Lynn Bourne held up for him - of course, he ended up in the obligatory sequined jumpsuit; Shae-Lynn Bourne doing a tango with a chair to an Italian song (or was it Spanish?); Surya Bonaly (totally forgettable sorry); Pang/Tong, who skated beautifully to a song that sounded like Bocelli, but my mom didn't think it was; and Johnny Weir, who skated to the Stevie Wonder song he did at Marshall's. He was fabulous.

I think Victor Petrenko was in the first act but couldn't swear to it - and I'm sorry, but I'm totally blanking on what he skated to, but I remember thinking he did a pretty good job.

Belbin/Agosto closed the first act with their hip-hop number. Oh dear. For those of you who saw the Marshall's broadcast (which I taped and watched last night), she changed her shorts - basically she's wearing boy short-type underwear, with fishnet stickings and sparkly over-the-boot knee highs (that were part of her and some of the other ladies' finale costume and I guess she figured they'd go nicely in her number) that made it look like she was wearing knee-high boots. Sorry, but if Ben is wearing a shirt, vest, and tie (and long pants), Tanith does not need to dress like a lap dancer. I have no issues with the bra top or baring her midriff, but I think a pair of leggings (they can be tight, low-rise, sparkly, whatever) would be a lot more tasteful. I also wasn't fond of their Detroiter-type lift where Ben wraps his arm around her crotch - one of the things that I've liked about B/A is that their moves are usually tastefully done, compared to some other dance teams. Aside from that move and Tanith's icky costume, I thought the skating was well done and they seemed to be enjoying themselves. I have to add, though, that Tanith really looks scary - way too thin. In the finale, when she was dressed in the same outfit as some of the other women, you could really see the difference - she was thinner than Sasha....and that's not something I thought could ever be said. 8O

Second act started off with Hula Hoop Woman Part II. I'll be kind and spare the details. Again, I'm a little fuzzy on who skated in what order. Anissina/Peizerat did some weird number about the circus and Gwendal starts out as ringmaster. Then the music changes, they lie on the ice to a few bars of the "Hurt" song that Sasha skates to (I'm thinking, WTF?). Then, the music changes again (at which point Gwendal changed his shirt, accompanied by some hoots and hollers from the audience - lol) and they skate to some other semi-upbeat song. It was odd.

Evan skated the INXS number ("Need You Tonight") and skated very well. Lots of screams and squeals from the (teenage?) girls in the audience.

Kimmie skated to Sarah MacLachlan's "Angel" in a different costume than she wore at Marshall's - this one was lavender with sparkles and wings on the sleeves. She skated beautifully, although I wish she had held her spiral positions longer, as they were very pretty. She popped a 3 lutz, but otherwise did everything very well.

Tot/Mar did a nice number to some slow music that I didn't recognize.

Acrobats somewhere in this act - wore 18th century wigs and velvet vest/suit outfits and started off skating to "Four Seasons" which quickly changed to "Rock Me Amadeus". They really annoy me, but the crowd liked them, and as long as they're getting a crowd response, I'm sure Tom Collins will keep them. Hula Hooper didn't get as much of a response, but I suppose it's wishful thinkng that she would be replaced with a real skater or skaters.

Shizuka skated to "I Have a Love" from West Side Story and she was fabulous. I must say that I've never been a huge fan of hers (not that I don't think her wins were well-deserved) but she really won me over with this number. It was really beautiful skating, no gimmicks, with nice spins and spirals and of course, her Ina Bauer.

Plushenko skated to an instrumental rock-type piece that I think he has skated to before. He landed 1 or 2 2 axels (can't remember exactly) and a 3 toe, and had a straight-line footwork sequence that was very Yagudin-esque and was punctuated by extended posing at each end (before and after the sequence). Other than that, the program was surprisingly gimmick-free.

Sasha skated to "Hurt" and did a great job. She landed a 2 axel and 3 sal and had a beautiful flying camel, Charlotte, and other spiral moves. I really hope she sticks with show skating and leaves competitive skating up to Kimmie, Mao, and Yu-Na. I'd much rather watch her enjoying herself and skating her heart out in a setting like this than see her wound up and stressed out and making mistakes at comps. OK, so she *only* got silver at Olys and Worlds, so what? A gold medal doesn't make or break your achievements. Since Michelle is not on the tour this year, Sasha is the headliner, and she filled MK's shoes very well. Maybe it's the acting classes, who knows, but she looks really comfortable and happy out there.

The finale was a James Bond theme and they used several different movie songs - started off with the standard intro theme and then I recognized "You Only Live Twice", "Goldfinger", and "Live and Let Die." Lots of small-group numbers-within-a-number and there were these plastic (although it must have been some specially-treated material b/c some skaters stood or kneeled on them on their blades) cube/prism type blocks that were pushed around the ice and carried skaters at certain points. It ended with everyone in a circle around the blocks and Evan standing on one block facing one side and Johnny standing on another block facing the other side.

Funny footnote: My mom and I were looking through the program and in the candid photos (Behind the Scenes) pages, there are about 5 pics of Tanith and Evan either by themselves or with others looking cuddly and 'together'. My mom asked me if they were dating. I replied yes and reminded her that ABC mentioned it about 10 times on the Nats broadcast, but my mom pointed out that she missed part of the men's comp, b/c she fell asleep - hey, it was on pretty late - lol.

Lark
04-15-2007, 04:02 PM
Lordie, that sounds like a packed field! I would have loved to have seen that!

Did Johnny and Gregory/Petukov do that number they did for Marshalls??? That was the bomb! :bow:

blackmanskating
04-17-2007, 05:51 PM
Well I would have to say that my experience with champions on ice was far different from Debbie's. I will say that I had a great time. This was my first time going to any COI tour so I was new to the experience. I had no idea what to expect. I couldn't find anyone to go with me so I went solo. I got a good seat. I was in section 100 Row D Seat 10 on the 4th row and my seat was in the middle of the rink. I mean It was lined up with the red center line on the ice. I could see everything. Now I managed to "smuggle" in a bag of twizzlers and a bottle of gatorade rain. But then again, I was there at 1:15 when the show started at 3 pm.

When got off the subway headed to the Verizon Center, some of my friends from my ISI skate club saw me and tapped me on the shoulder. They informed me of a reception party on the second floor and asked me if I was going. Naturally, I didn't know anything about a reception so I said no. So they tried to get me in. My friend's name was listed on the VIP list twice so they added my name in place of the duplicate!!! Now I'm feeling really good and rather silly at the same time because everyone at this reception is wearing business casual wear. I'm wearing regular clothing so I felt out of place. My friend assured me that I would have a good time up here. They had a refreshement table laid out and were serving drinks. There were about 35 people there.

To make a long story short, they brought six of the skaters up there to meet and greet us before the show started. The skaters were: Sasha Cohen, Kimmie Meissner, Evan Lysacek, Tanith Belbin, Ben Agosto, and my favorite skater Johnny Weir!!! :bow:I almost choked on my bottled water when they called his name and he came walking in to sit down!!! I was not expecting this. My friends didn't tell me. The kids in the room formed a line to shake hands and take pictures. They gave us all complementary programs and all 6 skaters signed them. I got to meet everybody and had a small conversation with Johnny Weir. Just as I told Johnny that he was my favorite skater, a camera crew rushed over to me to ask me why. This made me a little nervous but I answered their question as best as I could. I finally took a picture with Johnny. All of the skaters were incredibly nice. Sasha is such a professional. She's signing an autograph and having a conversation with us without even looking down at the paper. And I'll be the first to say that Tanith Belbin looked hot!!! Evan is a lucky guy if their relationship isn't a publicity stunt. She is beautiful in every regard. But I didn't appreciate the trashy outfit she wore when she was skating to Justin Timberlake. I like my ladies to be classy, and that performance kinda ruined the sweet girl image she portrayed at the reception.

My fav performances were from Johnny Weir(even though he fell on his triple lutz), Dan Hollander, Shizuka Arakawa, Vladimir and Oleski, Surya Bonaly, Rudy Galindo (funny), and Sasha Cohen. But I enjoyed every performance; even the catwoman thing. I liked the fact that Irina Gregorian came out there twice with two different types of performances because she broke up the monotony of the show. She made it a show instead of making it an exhibition performance from everyone. She did things that you don't see done in competition and that's what makes it truly entertaining. The hula hoop spiral thing was off the chain!!! The only thing I didn't like was the James Bond finale at the end. It wasn't that the performance was bad, but there was too much going on at once. You got one person spinning over here and another person doing a triple toe on the other side of the rink. It just seemed like I was struggling to catch everything that was going on. It had no focus at all until the very end of it.

All in all, I liked 98% of everything that was going on!! To be honest, I didn't miss Michelle Kwan at all. Every performer had something that I loved that made it a real show!!! I had a good time and I plan on seeing it again next year.

BlackManSkating

Debbie S
04-17-2007, 06:22 PM
Well I would have to say that my experience with champions on ice was far different from Debbie's. I will say that I had a great time. Far different? :?? Uh, where did I say I didn't like the show? I thought I made it clear that overall, I thought the show was good, but there were some acts and other things I could have done without. I would rather watch real skating than someone dressed as Cat Woman roll around in a life-size version of a rodent's toy on the ice....but different strokes for different folks - I realize others feel differently, otherwise Tom Collins wouldn't have her on the tour.

The "VIP reception" your friends smuggled you into was a fundraiser for the skating program for inner city kids at the Ft. Dupont rink. Tickets were $95 a person. That's nice that you got in for free and essentially stiffed the charity out of money. :roll:

blackmanskating
04-17-2007, 07:38 PM
Far different? Uh, where did I say I didn't like the show? I thought I made it clear that overall, I thought the show was good, but there were some acts and other things I could have done without. I would rather watch real skating than someone dressed as Cat Woman roll around in a life-size version of a rodent's toy on the ice....but different strokes for different folks

Ummm. . . I'm sorry that you took my post the wrong way. And I never said that you didn't have a good time. I just said that my experience and opinion was far different than yours. And secondly, check your facts before you accusing people of stiffing anybody. My friends' name was listed twice because she donated twice plus she had two tickets left over. So yes, I got in for free. But she essentially paid my way. And if somebody invited you to a function and allowed you to get in, would you honestly turn down the invitation because you didn't physically donate $95 to whatever cause? And I can't stiff anyone out of anything that I didn't know about previously. Jealous much??? :mrgreen: The next time you misinterpret what I say, have the decency to ask for clarification instead of going off on a jealous bit of rage. In the future, I'll double check my wording for the easily offended.

The "VIP reception" your friends smuggled you into was a fundraiser for the skating program for inner city kids at the Ft. Dupont rink. Tickets were $95 a person. That's nice that you got in for free and essentially stiffed the charity out of money.

Your response is completely unneccessary and I find myself laughing at your infantile attempt at being sarcastic. And it amazes me how folks can talk some good stuff but can't put their money where their mouth is. You seem to know so much about the "inner city figure skater's struggle" and how much it costs to contribute. But I can almost guarantee that you didn't contribute one red cent to that cause. But you gonna sit there and try to criticize me about something I didn't know about? You obviously don't know who you're dealing with. So don't sit here on this forum trying to open your mouth for a cause that you wouldn't open your wallet for. Talk is cheap lady, and your opinion isn't worth two cents.

BlackManSkating

Isk8NYC
04-18-2007, 02:49 PM
On first read, I took it to mean that blackmanskating was saying that, while you had a "good" time, he had an absolute blast. Everything was all-new to him and he was dazzled by it. The meet-and-greet experience, entirely due to a chance meeting - what good fortune! You have to admit that his first experience at COI was tremendous. (Congrats, btw)

I wouldn't have assumed that he attended the reception without any money changing hands. For our Church's 25th Anniversary celebration, we had a celebration that was more expensive than our usual year-to-year events. One couple could not make the dinner, but they purchased a table for six and gave us instructions to donate the seats to some older parishioners who were living on a fixed income.

My DH is a fundraising professional and I've gone to more events with already-paid-for empty chairs than I care to remember. Since we usually arrange for City Harvest to pick up the leftovers, food doesn't go to waste, but the empty chairs are a bigger issue. People who attend fundraisers know this, and often bring last-minute guests or buy extra seats upfront. Honestly, DH sees those empty seats as an opportunity to introduce new last-minute guests to the Charity at events like this. Often, an additional contribution comes from being hospitable to unexpected guests. We've been invited as guests of people being honored for awards and we always give a contribution, even though we didn't "pay" for our dinners.

BMS - Again, welcome to SkatingForums. That was a great story, thanks for sharing it with us.

Did anyone else go to this event? Want to chime in here?

flippet
04-18-2007, 02:51 PM
Okay, let's everybody calm down, and move on.

Thank you.

~flippet

blackmanskating
04-18-2007, 04:04 PM
On first read, I took it to mean that blackmanskating was saying that, while you had a "good" time, he had an absolute blast. Everything was all-new to him and he was dazzled by it. The meet-and-greet experience, entirely due to a chance meeting - what good fortune! You have to admit that his first experience at COI was tremendous. (Congrats, btw)


Thanks so much!!!!! I truly was blown away by my experience at COI last Saturday and I'm glad that you understood what I was trying to say. I wasn't trying to offend anyone. The meet and greet was truly a blessing. I was just grateful to be a part of it. Thanks again for welcoming to skating forums.


Okay, let's everybody calm down, and move on.

Thank you.

~flippet


Flippet, as far as I'm concerned, this was a dead issue as of yesterday. I enjoyed myself last weekend, but I refuse to let someone accuse me of something that I did not do. So, I said what I said and I left it alone

flippet
04-18-2007, 04:19 PM
Flippet, as far as I'm concerned, this was a dead issue as of yesterday. I enjoyed myself last weekend, but I refuse to let someone accuse me of something that I did not do. So, I said what I said and I left it alone

Except that you're bringing it up again.

This is what I mean by "move on". The thread (as a whole) was reported, and my post was preemptive moderation. Past experience shows that it is often necessary.

~flippet

blackmanskating
04-18-2007, 04:55 PM
Except that you're bringing it up again.


That was not my intention. It is already over. :giveup:

Isk8NYC
04-18-2007, 05:01 PM
Thread closed.